South metro area Catholics are rejoicing at news that a priest
who served for nine years at St. Thomas More Church in Centennial
has been cleared of sexual abuse charges by the Denver
Archdiocese.
Father Mel Thompson, St. Thomas More’s assistant pastor, was
removed from service last April one day after an unnamed man
alleged that the priest had abused him at an undisclosed church in
the mid-1970s.
The Archdiocese referred the matter to Denver police, but no
criminal investigation was launched due to the statute of
limitations.
The Archdiocese announced this month that Thompson, 75, has been
cleared by a church investigation and was offered reinstatement.
The priest was granted a requested retirement instead.
Michael Kirrane, a lector coordinator at St. Thomas More, was in
the pews Jan. 2 when a letter from Archbishop Charles Chaput, the
church official who had removed Thompson, was read to
parishioners.
“The place just erupted in cheers and clapping and the longest
ovation I have heard in a long time,” Kirrane said. “Everybody that
I know is absolutely thrilled that [Thompson has] been cleared on
all charges.”
Chaput’s statement said the Archdiocesan Conduct Response Team
concluded that the accusations against Thompson are not supported
by the evidence.
According to Archdiocese spokeswoman Jeanette DeMelo, the team
that cleared the priest consisted of two psychologists, a retired
police detective, a retired judge and the Archdiocese’s vicar for
clergy. Most are Catholic laypersons.
Kirrane says the panel’s conclusions are consistent with what he
knows about Thompson’s character.
“Father Mel is one of the most devoted people to the Lord. It’s
just outside the realm of belief that he would do anything like
that,” Kirrane said.
The investigative panel reached its conclusion unanimously after
interviewing people involved in the case. Members of the panel were
not identified due to privacy concerns, DeMelo added.
Jeb Barrett, director of the Denver chapter of Survivors Network
of Those Abused by Priests, insists the investigation has no
credibility because it was organized by church officials.
“I think every survivor of childhood sexual assault should be
outraged,” Barrett said. “The outrage is they think anybody is
going to swallow the idea that a self-investigation is going to be
accepted by anybody with any brains.”
The alleged 1970s incident was not the only time Thompson has
been accused of sexual misconduct. In a 7News report aired in May
2010, a man said the priest propositioned him at Lakewood’s Our
Lady of Fatima Church when the man was a college student in the
1990s.
In response to a request for a comment on the 7News report,
DeMelo wrote in an e-mail, “The heart of the Conduct Response
Team’s review is that Father Mel poses no threat to the safety of
anyone.”
Efforts to contact Thompson were not successful.